WELCOME TO OLD CUTLER BAY
The gated community of Old Cutler Bay was founded in the early 60’s. Old Cutler Bay is situated off of scenic Old Cutler Road and just 1 block south of North Kendall Drive. There are 136 homes in Old Cutler Bay, 127 of them being waterfront homes with no bridges to Biscayne Bay. The 10 foot wrought iron sculpture “A World of Its Own” which is predominantly featured in the main entrance of Old Cutler Bay, was donated by developer Albert Aronson to the City of Coral Gables and dedicated to the community of Old Cutler Bay in 1965. Since June of 1986, Old Cutler Bay became a voluntary homeowners association. Membership approval is not required to purchase or lease a home in Old Cutler Bay.
PEOPLE & LIFESTYLE
The average lot size in Old Cutler Bay is 24,600 SF, while the average home is 4,680 SF. Of the 136 homes and lots, practically all of Old Cutler Bay residents are homeowners, with a very little margin of renters in place. The average household earns in excess of $250,000 per year. The average age of residents is 52.
PARKS & NATURE
Old Cutler Bay residents enjoy easy accessibility to many of the parks nearby. A short walk away is Matheson Hammock Park & Marina. For the garden-enthusiast, you have Fairchild Tropical Botanic Garden. Just minutes away are Dante Fascell Park – with a great family playground and Pinecrest Gardens with a brand-new playground. You can’t miss the Farmer’s Market, every Sunday. The walking/bike paths make it easy to explore the great outdoors.
RESTAURANTS
Old Cutler Bay provides an array of selections for a great meal.
SHOPPING
Old Cutler Bay is conveniently located nearby markets such as Publix, Whole Foods, Mariner’s Seafood and Graziano’s Market in the Gables for a variety of Argentine cuts of meat, cheeses and wines.
Old Cutler Bay is close to local conveniences such as pharmacies, a post office, banks, medical and dental offices, pet shops, a hardware store and more.
SCHOOLS
Public:
- Sunset Elementary School, International Magnet program, grades PK - 5
- Ponce De Leon Middle School, Magnet and IB program, grades 6 – 8
- Coral Gables Senior High, Magnet and IB program, grades 9-12
Private:
- Our Lady of Lourdes Academy, all girls, grades 9 – 12
- Epiphany Catholic School, grades PK – 8
- Gulliver Preparatory Academy, grades PK3 - 12
- Riviera Day School, grades PK – 5
- Alexander Montessori Schools, grades PK – 5
- The French American School of Miami, grades PK3 – 5
Dennis’s Notable Transactions in Old Cutler Bay
- 625 Reinante Avenue - $47,000,000 (2026)
- 555 Reinante Ave - $40,000,000 (2025, off-market sale)
- 555 Reinante Ave - $21,500,000 (2022)
- 9320 Balada Street - $17,950,000
- 505 Solano Prado - $14,200,000
- 180 Solano Prado - $13,000,000 *
- 9375 Balada Ave - $10,410,000 (off-market sale)
- 535 Solano Prado - 9,500,000
- 600 Marquesa Dr - $5,350,000
- 620 Reinante Ave - $5,100,000
- 625 Reinante Ave - $5,000,000 (2017)
- 70 Solano Prado - $4,200,000
- 540 Reinante Ave - $3,700,000
*Transaction Broker for Seller and Buyer
WELCOME TO OLD CUTLER BAYThe gated community of Old Cutler Bay was founded in the early 60’s. Old Cutler Bay is situated off of scenic Old Cutler Road and just 1 block south of North Kendall Drive. There are 136 homes in Old Cutler Bay, 127 of them being waterfront homes with no bridges to Biscayne Bay. The 10 foot wrought iron sculpture “A World of Its Own” which is predominantly featured in the main entrance of Old Cutler Bay, was donated by developer Albert Aronson to the City of Coral Gables and dedicated to the community of Old Cutler Bay in 1965. Since June of 1986, Old Cutler Bay became a voluntary homeowners association. Membership approval is not required to purchase or lease a home in Old Cutler Bay.
PEOPLE & LIFESTYLEThe average lot size in Old Cutler Bay is 24,600 SF, while the average home is 4,680 SF. Of the 136 homes and lots, practically all of Old Cutler Bay residents are homeowners, with a very little margin of renters in place. The average household earns in excess of $250,000 per year. The average age of residents is 52.
PARKS & NATUREOld Cutler Bay residents enjoy easy accessibility to many of the parks nearby. A short walk away is Matheson Hammock Park & Marina. For the garden-enthusiast, you have Fairchild Tropical Botanic Garden. Just minutes away are Dante Fascell Park – with a great family playground and Pinecrest Gardens with a brand-new playground. You can’t miss the Farmer’s Market, every Sunday. The walking/bike paths make it easy to explore the great outdoors.
RESTAURANTSOld Cutler Bay provides an array of selections for a great meal.
SHOPPINGOld Cutler Bay is conveniently located nearby markets such as Publix, Whole Foods, Mariner’s Seafood and Graziano’s Market in the Gables for a variety of Argentine cuts of meat, cheeses and wines.
Old Cutler Bay is close to local conveniences such as pharmacies, a post office, banks, medical and dental offices, pet shops, a hardware store and more.
SCHOOLSPublic:
Sunset Elementary School, International Magnet program, grades PK - 5Ponce De Leon Middle School, Magnet and IB program, grades 6 – 8Coral Gables Senior High, Magnet and IB program, grades 9-12Private:
Our Lady of Lourdes Academy, all girls, grades 9 – 12Epiphany Catholic School, grades PK – 8Gulliver Preparatory Academy, grades PK3 - 12Riviera Day School, grades PK – 5Alexander Montessori Schools, grades PK – 5The French American School of Miami, grades PK3 – 5Dennis’s Notable Transactions in Old Cutler Bay
625 Reinante Avenue - $47,000,000 (2026)555 Reinante Ave - $40,000,000 (2025, off-market sale)555 Reinante Ave - $21,500,000 (2022)9320 Balada Street - $17,950,000505 Solano Prado - $14,200,000 180 Solano Prado - $13,000,000 *9375 Balada Ave - $10,410,000 (off-market sale)535 Solano Prado - 9,500,000600 Marquesa Dr - $5,350,000620 Reinante Ave - $5,100,000625 Reinante Ave - $5,000,000 (2017)70 Solano Prado - $4,200,000540 Reinante Ave - $3,700,000*Transaction Broker for Seller and Buyer
